Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 STHR GHTE DT-9-1032-SL **too DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY PROJECT OVERSIGHT PHnEL.(U) MINUTES OF FIRST MEETING 9 flPHIL 199 1 NOF01m STHR GHTE LIMID318 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 Approved For Release 3maim= = 96-00789R002900550001-0 0 L.%j PROJECT OVERSIGHT PANEL MINUTES OF FIRST MEETING 9 APRIL 1991 CLASSIFIED BY: DIA/DT DECLASSIFY ON: OADR Q m - Approved For Release 2000Q/V4lM- D 0789R002900550001 -0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 TABLE OF CONTENTS. PAGE I. PURPOSE I II. BACKGROUND 1 III. DISCUSSION 1 ENCLOSURE 1 - ATTENDEES ENCLOSURE 2 - OVERSIGHT PANEL CHARTER ENCLOSURE 3 - DT-S CHARTER Approved For Release 2000/08/08 CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 Approved For Release 20W06Y. =I- 196-00789R002900550001 -0 PROJECT OVERSIGHT PANEL SGU I. (U) PURPOSE: (U) The purpose of this report is to document results of the first meeting of the Project Oversight Panel and to identify its basic role for the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA). Ii. (U) BACKGROUND: (SINF) A STAR GATE Project Oversight Panel has been established in order to review the overall approach used by the DIA Assistant Deputy Directorate for Scientific and Technical Intelligence regarding evaluation and assessment of STAR GATE data. Oversight Panel members represent a diversity of scientific and management backgrounds and were drawn from DIA's Advisory Board, from the DIA General Council (GC), and from the DIA Inspector General (IG) office. These individuals are as follows: Mr. Mr- Mr. Robert L. Smith Dr. Clarence H. Stewart General Dynamics, Pomona, CA Proc'essing Research, Inc., Vienna, VA Dr. Michael A. Wartell Sandia National Laboratory, Albuquerque, NM This panel is chaired by Dr. Wartell. III. (U) DISCUSSION: SGU (U) The first Oversight Panel meeting was held on 9 April present. Others present were DT), and representatives from DT-3, DT-5 and DT-S. The meeting attendees are shown at enclosure 1. SGU (SINF) At this first meeting, provided welcome and introductory remarks, discussed overall meeting objectives, summarized project background, and reviewed the charters for the Oversight Panel (enclosure 2) and the STAR GATE activity (enclosure 3). The primary function of the Oversight Panel is to provide the Assistant Deputy Director for Scientific and Technical Intelligence advice/council on STAR GATE project R I Qr.QQr.a; W Approved t'0WmJKQW16VtXZV4"U1P1U0 -- 114684 W100789R002900550001 -0 t-% r- ^ r-% QW Approved For Release /.UIEZMW.RIMLIVtlb-uO789ROO2900550001 -0 activities management and procedures, and to provide guidance on the evaluation and assessment for the data generated by project STAR GATE-SG1J (U) then presented additional details on project evolution and recent activity. The Panel had numerous detailed questions and pursued many avenues of discussion that helped provide additional insight. Not all questions could be addressed in the depth desired due to time constraints. Consequently, the Panel could not draw firm conclusions on all of the program aspects as identified in the Panel Charter. The Panel members felt that additional briefings/discussions would be required to permit an in-depth review of project evolution, previous research support, current directions,"and research activities. The panel also expressed interest in reviewing future research objectives and long range plans. (U) Even though not all objectives of this first meeting were met, the Panel was pleased with the frankness/candor in which all questions were addressed. For some Panel members, this was their first exposure to this topic; the background and tutorial aspects of the replies were greatly appreciated. (U) The Panel agreed to hold the next meeting on 30 May 1991 at the DIAC in order to continue their in-depth review that would focus on previous work and future goals/directions. It was also recommended that Dr. Ed May, the principle researcher in this area, be invited to present details of the research history and upcoming research activity. (U) Minute preparation was then initiated and the meeting was adjourned on schedule. Approve-'e'N r= ^. r0% ==1118/08 : CIA- M19RO02900550001 -0 C..; L~VTX _~ - - U - ~ " '. ~ A~l Ff 3 Enclosures 1. Attendance List (S) 1 Cy 2. Oversight Panel Charter (SINF) 1 cy SGFOIA3 3. DT-S Charter (SINF) 1 Cy Approved For Release '-A I MVP q f; - 0 01789ROO2900550001 -0 =X.*-# I x me SG1J MR. ROBERT L. SMITH DR. CLARENCE H. STEWART ATTENDANCE LIST DIA/GC DIA/IG GENERAL DYNAMICS PROCESSING RESEARCH, INC. SANDIA NATIONAL LABORATORY DIA/DT DIA/DT DIA/DT-5 DIA/DT-3B DIA/DT-S DIA/DT-S MI: ?!:WRIDP96-0078 Approved For Release 25dfts 9R002900550001 -0 ENCLOSURE 1 DR. MICHAEL A. WARTELL S G-Tj Approved For Release Lwlep% -00789 ROO 2900550001 -0 OVERSIGHT PANEL CHARTER m :;z CD cn ;a m 0 THE PRIMARY FUNCTION OF THE OVERSIGHT PANEL IS TO PROVIDE THE ASSISTANT DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL INTELLIGENCE ADVICE/COUNCIL ON STAR GATE PROJECTACTIVITIES, MANAGEMENT, AND PROCEDURES, AND TO PROVIDE GUIDANCE ON THE EVALUATION AND ASSESSMENT PROCESS FOR THE DATA GENERATED BY PROJECT STAR GATE. THE OVERSIGHT PANEL WILL MEET PERIODICALLY TO RECEIVE UPDATE BRIEFINGS AND TO REVIEW RELEVANT PROJECT DOCUMENTATION. 789ROO2900550001-0 Approved ForW%6p~Awm 4W0 Approved For Release(2i~,r7/m",%Ai0lFm"j"- VMR002900550001 -0 DT~S CHARTER 1. EXTERNAL RESEA - EXTERNAL SUPPORT - PARTICIPATE IN PROJECTS - DEVELOP APPROPRIATE ASSESSMENT /EVALUATION PROCEDURES - -DEVELOP LONG RANGE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN m CD 2. FOREIGN ASSESSMENT - IDENTIFY COLLECTION REQUIREMENTS - IMPLEMENT PLANS - DEVELOP WORLDWIDE INTEGRATED DATA BASE - PREPARE FOREIGN ASSESSMENTS 3. IN-HOUSE INVESTIGATIONS - SUPPORT RESEARCH; OBTAIN APPROPRIATE EQUIPMENT - DEVELOP PROCEDURES - PURSUE POTENTIAL APPLICATIONS (NOT TO THE DETRIMENT OF 1. & 2.) =0 r% =r.. WaU 11401/08 Ir 89FI Approved%QXV;w lollff%, 96-00~, 74 R400550001 -0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 TIME FUNME RCTIUITY ''' 1992 1994 1995 1996 State Partmetors OS,Z~ Pbysiology PERSONNEL (HEG);1 etc. S.ELECTION psy0bology USENRCH (Solt Report, BeVivioral tZeasures, etc. Solicit Empirical (mass screening) Ug) State Parameters .......................... RSONNEL (Aaterod States, Subliminal Thresb6ld measures, eetc.)) HINING *oal Evaluation. Practical w'SERRCH Application Tests hL -- I "I - --A ' 0. N (Increasing P;ojoct D12210MY ) Characteristics Target PPLICHTION A (Entropy, rl-zeetc ENBLURTION Otber Asnots (Target 9E'SE'HRCH Functio-- a, Degree ol Importance, etc.) Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 TIME FRNME - SICTIVITY 1992 _ L1 994., T 1995 1996 DEVELOP EUBLONTION CRITERIII PEAFORM HISTORICAL d RNALYS I S MATA BASE ' EH;MINE VARIOUS TECIMICAL TAFq1w Tflit ING" %GET 'LABORATORY 813= SVITEMS JCT ADVANCED SENSORS or COMPLEX COMPOYRNM UnIONTION ERIFERIMENTS FAR-IFIRLD EFlrxcrm P11.11SUE (COUNTIFIdMAZURES) R"LICRTIONS PtRSONNEI. SOLICiT SCPZENING /mmail4imq 1 -4 ........ SELECTION 0 0 (M4OWN TALENT) (DEVEWP) Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 MLO ne [g~gg g1ragggan U0, gM"g,~, L TIME FURME - RCTIIJITV 1992 1993 71994 1"5 lularmation/Entropy SOURCE Analysis ........ ............................... RESERVICH lova Target Attributes (TORGET) .............. (Size, Form, Content3 lour-Dimtnxicn r Calcul&4 ~! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M (Relativity Extens x TURNSMISSION PY#ctdr and ScAlar.Wayw! - - - 4f RESERRCH -(Laboratory) o n g (MECHHNISMS) Variables .............. Rdelding, 1%urosciance DETECTOR (MO, t*morr7eCM. uvircrimental HESERRCH Factors ,.' ABBRIN) Other Physiology AY.... (Electrical, Infrar Implications Irom dedical/Animal L-=**~rc Physical Sciences I NTEGRIITI (Pbrsics, ON Statistics, Parallel PrIeSSIXG, Psuhol%~fjal Sciences Psyebology, Axttb~cjsology, Cogvltive, Mntal, Subliminal Perception, @to.) Mdical Genetics, eto.) Approved For Release 2000108108: CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001-0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 WITH TYPES fICTIVITY * TIP-OFF * COUNTERTERRORISM * CONCERLMENT * COUNTEIINRRCOTI CS + Sfflucu/Tgacic * COUNTERINTELLIGENCE +1RESOURCE LOCRTION COMMUNICHTION + FRC;4L ITY ORTH S V T RNRLYSIS * SECIOR I-fY SYSTEMS RRIER CONFLICTS * FOR 116N PERSONBLITY COUNTERMERSURES THTE OF HERLTH HUMINT RCTIIJITY SUPPORT .~,BEBHIEF MEDICHL SUPPORT * PHEDICTIIJE * E01FIPMENT INFLUENCE * PEWFOHMRNCE ENHHNCEMENT + ME0_ICRL HECOIJE19Y Approved For Release 2000/08/08 CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 I Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-0,0789ROO2900550001 -0 AINLEMON 11 via &" 0 kc SUMM17tibilit-Y -Physiology Candidate R4weiver Sell report T Selected populatio2w Proloodure- r myscific PI Criteria tor elected 0yulatiorm nay PAS Behavioral Candidate xxits Prograa Others Approved For Release 2000/08/08 CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 I Approved For Release 2000/08/08 CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 T raijdw Proo"Was SUbliMirAl Threshold Altered States Practical tical ispee &list ic Application i C ERP : I L B - Test-Bed . d . . back Blofe ad rM a Is specialist 2.rw DD*;~wn~d Bas ion Criteria r ck Feedba %%ing S ial'st Conditio D Failed t1inimum Failed t1inimum Criteria for CrIteria. S~Mialist Cal Empiri Acceptamce. Receiver Exits E L Program Procedure is Abandoned Others Approved For Release 2000/08/08 CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 Approved For Release 2000/08/08: CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001 -0 (Ora 9(o NOTE TIME FRNME BCTIUI TV 1992 1993 1994 996 oporatxozal Corditioms A :PROTOCOL Feedback, etc.) DEUELOPMENT Starch/Location, Projec ........ YCW &PPlications/Proo*durfs pas rao Defizdtion a, irp;zAroz, etc.) (Written, Dr&VA, PhYSiOlO Tc (W tt: Artilicial ETHOU intelligence &rt, (Fvzxy EUELOPMENT Sets, etc.) &Vlral 10twork Analo ................ ,Combination ol Mvt~ ~d 1utelli2!uc* Data pus tbods W, ............... ORTO tNTESBUTION ISSIMILSTION t4-yanotd -Traininq~ 10EUELOPMENT ~ariouz Consumers7 Approved For Release 2000/08/08: CIA-RDP96-00789ROO2900550001-0