Annrn VQCLFor Release 2000/08/07 CIA-RQP96-00788r001300280002-7 ry 1982 Februa Final Report Covering the Period October 1980 to September 1981 RV RELIABILITY, ENHANCEMENT, AND ID EVALUATION (U) NM ~. W21ed For Release 2000/08/07: CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl 30028000-7 Approved For Release 2 96-00788r001300280002-7 CONTENTS LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v low LIST OF TABLES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v EW I OBJECTIVE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 II INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 3 III RV ENHANCEMENT TASK . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 A. Tasking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 . . . . . B. Coordinate RV (CRV) . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 . . . . . C. Overview of the RV Enhancement Procedure . . . 8 . . . . . D. Transfer of RV Enhancement Technology . . . . 11 . . . . . E. 'Summary of the RV Enhancement Technique . . . 13 . . . . . IV *RV TASKS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 . . j A. RV Tasking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 B. RV Session Format . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 . . . . . C. Pre- and Post!.' Task Calibration . . . . . . . 15 D. FY 198i" -,JRV Sites . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 . E. Evaluation of the RV Task . . . . . . . . . 20 V SUMMARY . . 21 OF THE FY 1981 RV ENHANCEMENT TASK . . . . . . . Appendices A REPRESENTATIVE SAMPLE OF CRV PRACTICE SITES . . 23 . . . . B ="TASK SUMMARY SHEETS . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 C AN EXAMPLE OF A REMOTE VIEWING RESPONSE . . . 53 . . . . . D -RV EVALUATION PROTOCOLS . . . . . . . . . . 61 E A SAMPLE RETURNED EVALUATION PROTOCOL . . . . 69 . . . . . iii Approved For Release 20001C -~346-0078MOI 300280002-7 0, Approved For Release 20C~,~ ---_796-00788r001300280002-7 ILLUSTRATIONS 1 RV Enhancement Program . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 2 Schematic Representation of Remote Viewer Response to CRV Situation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 3 Stage 3 Remote Viewing (Wotje Atoll) . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 4 Presession Calibration Trial (Mount Kilimanjaro) (a) Site, (b) RV Response . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . 17 5 Postsession Calibration Trial (Canyonlands National Park) (a) Site, (b) RV Response . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 TABLES I Stages in Remote Viewing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 2 Remote Viewing Tasks (FY 1981) . . . . . ... . . 19 V Approved For Release 200 Ic 'P 6-00788r001 300280002-7 Approved For Release 200011L -_16-00788r001300280002-7 I OBJECTIVE The objective of the RV Reliability? Enhancement, and Evaluation Task is to develop techniques to enhance remote viewing (RV), both to I enhance the potential for.06 avvlications.~ Approved For Release 2 R P96-00788r001300280002-7 Approved For Release 200~- 76-00788rOOl 300280002-7 II INTRODUCTION SRI international is tasked with assessing the potential of RV for 1,, applications. In this task, as defined for fiscalyears (FY)- 1981 through 1983, special emphasis is placed on the possibility that enhancement techniques can be developed that will significantly increase levels of accuracy and reliability. The three-year effort focuses on (1) the development of techniques to enhance the accuracy and reliability of RV, (2) the application of RV (3) the evaluation of such techniques and applications, and (4) the integration of RV The apportionment of these efforts over the three-year period is shown in Figure 1. Investigation of the RV phenomenon at SRI International over the past decade has ranged from basic research for proof or the lack of proof of the existence of the phenomenon to applications in which the existence of the phenomenon is assumed. The present study emphasizing applicability is the latter type--proof of the phenomenon i's not explicitly pursued here. Some pragmatic measure of demonstration of existence is provided, however,,by assessment of the quality of results obtained in tests carried out under double-blind conditions. In this report we discuss the effort for FY'81. This effort con- sisted of: RV is the acquisition and description, by mental means, of information blocked from ordinary perception by distance or shielding. 3 Approved For Release 2000/ 00788r001300280002.7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : C17 001300280002-7 INTEG~ATION OF IiV. EVALUATION TASKING DEVELOPMENT OF ENHANCEMENT TECHNIQUES 1981 1982 1983 FISCAL YEAR FIGURE 1 (U) RV ENHANCEMENT PROGRAM 4 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA- -1013J0280002-7 f Approved For Release 2000/k,. 6-00788rOOl 300280002-7 (1) The development of a six-stage RV training procedure, which we hypothesized would lead to improved RV perf ormance. (2) The beginning of orientation/application/testing of the procedure with four experienced and one novice remote viewer. (3) The generation of data by the experienced remote viewers- (4) The development of a first-generation series of evaluation sheets (and an associated computerized data-base management system) for use by analysts in providing numerical estimates of various aspects of the RV product. 5 Approved For Release 206(0_~Iv i . ~,IA-J96-90788rO01 300280002-7 Approved For Release 200010 0788r001 300280002-7 III RV ENHANCEMENT TASK A. Tasking SRI International is tasked with working toward the development of RV enhancement procedures Of. particular interest are the development of procedures that can be transmitted to others in a structured fashion (i.e. training" procedures), and that can be used in targeting on distant sites, B. Coordinate RV (CRV) One targeting procedure, which we have been investigating at SRI since 1972, is an abstract procedure known as "coordinate remote viewing (CRV)." In this procedure, the target site coordinates (latitude and longitude in degrees, minutes, and seconds) are given (with no further information) to the individual who is to view the site. The remote viewer is then asked simply to proceed on the basis of the coordinates alone. Admittedly, such an abstract targeting procedure seems without basis, at least with regard to the present scientific paradigm. As a result we can make no claim for the technique other than the purely pragmatic one that it appears to work. It can only be pointed out that the possi- bility of success in such a protocol is in accord with an observed "goal- oriented" nature of the laws that appear to govern such functioning. An investigation into the general problem of target acquisition has been carried out and reported in R. Targ, H. Puthoff, B. Humphrey, and C. Tart, "Investigations of Target Acquisition," Research in Parapsychology, 1979 (Scarecrow Press, Inc., Metuchen, N.J., 1980). 7 Approved For Release 200 _00788r001 300280002-7 0400*93 r Approved For Release 2000/07~ CIA-R76-0078MO1300280002-7 C. Overview of the RV Enhancement Procedure Specifically under investigation at the present time is an RV enhancement procedure developed by I. Swann, an SRI consultant. The procedure focuses on improving reliability of remote viewing by controlling those factors that tend to introduce noise into the RV product. Following is a summary overview of the Swann CRV procedure. A detailed historical and technical summary is being prepared as a separate technical report. Two major sources of noise have been found: (1) noi-se caused by factors in the environment of the remote viewer, and (2) noise arising within the viewer as a result of cognitive processes (analysis/ MW interpretation). Noise from the environment, peripheral visual clutter or sounds in the environment (even subliminal) can intrude on perceptual and thought processes and degrade the RV response. Actions or statements by the session monitor can similarly distract the remote viewer. "Internally generated" noise seems to be produced in the remote viewer himself. With the application of a "stimulus" (e.g., the reading of a coordinate) a momentary burst of "signal" appears to enter into awareness for a few seconds and then fade away. At this point memory aw and imagination appear to fill in the void, thus producing",noise" in the RV product. This effect is presumably produced by a need to resolve Aw the ambiguity associated with the fragmentary nature of emerging percep- tions. (This relationship is schematically diagrammed in Figure 2.) To prevent this effect disciplined rejection of premature interpretations and conclusions is necessary. The techniques designed to handle these noise problems involve (1) repeated coordinate presentation and quick-reaction response on the part of the remote viewer to minimize the imaginative overlays, (2) the use of a specially designed, acoustic-tiled, featureless room with 8 Approved For Release 2000, J:-~ipq~_0078MO`l 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 UNCLASSIFIED Lu 0 z :c LL W CO C) w U) z W i ui ir w Z > 0 LL z 0 % 1 0 0 w z (D 0 z co D -i U, z z 0 cc w 0 2 w cr- LL 0 z 0 < z w U) Li cr 0. w cc < w 3: u 2 cli w cc LL UNCLASSIFIED Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 STAGES IN REMOTE VIEWING Stage Example (1) Major gestalt Land surrounded by water, an island (2) Sensory contact Cold sensation, wind-swept feeling (3) Dimension, motion, mobility Rising up, a panoramic view (4) Quantitative aspects Three large buildings, clustered together as a facility. (5) Special qualitative aspects Scientific research, live organisms (6) Significant analytical aspectsI 5Q_-P_ of site During FY 1981, Swann worked on developing the details of the six- stage RV enhancement procedure under investigation by serving as a remote viewer himself for over 200 training trials for sites from around the globe. Coordinates for site acquisition and data for feedback and analysis were obtained from National Geographic, World Aeronautical Charts, USGS topo- graphical maps and the like. To indicate the range and type of sites employed, a representative sample of sites used in CRV practice from November 1980 are listed in Appendix A. Approved For Release 2000108107 CIA 130028 (7P96- -0078 02-7 7 homogeneous coloring, to minimize environmental overlay, and (3) the adoption of a strictly Prescribed, limited monitor behavior to minimize monitor overlay. The training protocol as presently structured proceeds through a series of six stages of proficiency, hypothesized to correspond to six stages of increasing contact with the target site. These are outlined in Table 1. Table 1 .10 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 oriDor-n rOO1300280002-7 Approved For Release 200-0./08/07 DP96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 C7 - D. Transfer of RV Enhancement Technology Swann instructed three other experienced remote viewers (#009, #131, and #504) in theory classes. Application of the theory was carried out on the basis of practice RV training trials on around-the-globe sites (over 60 each) by the remote viewers. Toward the end of the FY 1981 effort, the first novice remote viewer (#622) was introduced into the training task so that we could begin to obtain data on the response of inexperienced personnel to the training program as structured. This remote viewer had over 50 RV trials. the program leaderily. Puthoff% A, observed the theory classes and acted asOmonitorp for several of the practice sessions to monitor the progress of the RV enhancement program. Both also acted as monitors for RV tasks, which provided additional data on progress of the program (Section IV). Although detailed formal evaluation of the training program is not scheduled until mid FY 1982, some general observations of progress in RV enhancement can be made. The experienced remote viewers (#009, #131, #504) were taken through Stage 3 in the theory,'orientation sessions, and reliable data were obtained through Stage 2 into Stage 3 in the RV training trials. The remote viewers experienced some difficulty in adjusting to this "retraining" because some of the experienced remote viewers had to modify the style which they had developed. This adoption of style did not, however, appear to interfere with their ability to, perform well using the RV enhancement techniques tinder study. Figure 3 is an example of what is meant by Stage 3 Remote Viewing (dimension, motion, mobility). The (blind) target site was Wotje At.oll in the Marshall Islands in the Pacific. For a good rendition an ability to "move" around the site is required to outline the shape of the island, associated reef, buildings, and so forth. 11 Approved For Release DP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 0 (D (D m Q Q Q Q 00 Q -4 0 r~ > to o Q m 4 00 00 Q Q Q Q m 00 Q Q Q 44 Sam,f 6Cli S- ;Lev J,,e( ~-,Lej- WOVE ATOLL BURNED-OUT --INL I" TRESTLE SAND SAND RUINS WOTJE AIRFI TANK SAND Luail. UNCLASSI F I ED FIGURE 3 (U) STAGE 3 REMOTE VIEWING (WOTJE ATOLL) V &W RUIN . , REEF AIRFIELD AREA COMPLETELY BOMB POCKED WOTJE ISLAND (D 0 X (D (D m Q Q Q Q 00 Q 4 0 > > m 6 Q -4 00 00 Q Q Q Q m 00 Q Q Q 44 Approved For Release .200C~, -00788rOO1300280002-7 ~P 6 The novice remote viewer was given orientation through Stage 2, and has produced reliable data through Stage I to date. In contrast with the experienced remote viewers, the novice viewer experienced no particular difficulty in becoming familiar with the codified RV enhancement procedure. E. Summary of the RV Enhancement Technique The RV enhancement techniques may be summarized as follows: (1) The codified multistage approach to data acquisition inherent in the RV enhancement procedure appears to ff slow down" the incoming data successfully, thereby M providing some safeguard against the natural tendencies of the remote viewer to interpret and AW analyze prematurely. (2) The data being generated within the structure being investigated appear to result in briefer transcripts with higher signal-to-noise ratios compared to previous results. The gain appears to be both in the quality of individual trials and in the reliability from trial to trial. (3) Knowledge of the hypothesized multistage process of site acquisition appears to provide some predictive value about the quality of the RV product. The data that do not emerge more or less in the staged order tend to have a higher percentage of overlay. 13 Approved For Release 20 6-00788rOOl 300280002-7 (CIC JQ9 This page intentionally left blank. 14 UNCLASSIFIED roved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 Cl 96-00788rOO 1300280002-7 IV RV TASKS RAW A. Rv Tasking SRI International is tasked with investi gating~~ applied RV, both to determine the potential.for application to. provide dataf- In response to this requirement, SRI has pursued application tasks of interest responding to quick-reaction requirements set by representatives monitoring the progress of the work. B. RV Session Format The format for carrying out these tasks during FY 1981 is as follows. A request for information is forwarded to COTR in residence at SRI. He then provides targeting information (e.g., coordinates) to an SRI RV session monitor at start of session, who then works with a remote viewer to obtain data. In this format, SRI personnel are generally blind to the source of the request and the type of site or event of interest. In many cases the COTR monitors the RV session, or even conducts the session himself. C. Pre- and Post 'Task Calibration In an effort to determine whether a remote viewer is "on-line" before attempting an '-task, a presession calibration trial of a site of the kind selected from the National Geographic is carried out. If the results are good, the task is engaged; if not, the task is aborted. In like fashiont a postsession calibration trial is carried out 15 Approved For Release 2000 '7 - -00788rOOl 300280002-7 0 7 -7 Approved For Release 2000/09/ 88rOO1300280002 to Provide an estimate of whether the viewer remained "on-line" during the' task. Examples of pre- and Post-session calibration trials for tite are shown in Figures 4 and 5. In these J.S. #17 examples the characteristics of the new technique under consideration can be noted: brevity of response from repeated coordinate presentation; aw physical sensations associated with the site; labeling of analytical X overlays (AOL) to distinguish them from signal; and general progression to through the stages. so In the case of these calibration trials accompanying Itsite J.S. #17, good results obtained in the calibration trials correlated well with good results on the-I task. Based on these kinds of resultsAt data will be collected throughout the program to determine whether pre- and M post- session calibration trials can reliably provide usefuL indicators for estimati ng the quality of data obtained in the RV task. D. FY 1981 The tasks carried out during FY 1981 are listed in Table 2. Additional detailed data are provided in the sk Summary Sheets provided in Appendix B. Complete documentation (transcripts, evaluations, etc.) can be made available An example of a RV response is given in Appendix C. as 16 now Approved For Release 200010SAW-' UA-RDP_1~078WO1300280002-7 ApppWRtFjqr RelUN GIIA&RHED)P96-00788r001 300280002-7 (a) 00a (b) N c_ 57' ;O'E -0. 4- A 17 Pf V1_t1_ - 0W4 CLI UNCLASSITIED We (AAI'O - FIGURE 4 (U) PRE-SESSION CALIBRATION TRIAL (MOUNT KILIMANJARO) (a) SITE, (b) RV RESPONSE 17 UNCLASSIFIED Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788r00130 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 . Cl anZAM01300280002-7 U UNCLAOSE CPYRGHT (a) ;2 IV 0 UNCLASSIFIED FIGURE 5 (U) POST-SESSION CALIBRATION TRIAL (CANYONLANDS NATIONAL PARK) (a) SITE, (b) RV RESPONSE 18 UNCLASSIFIED Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788r001300280002-7 (b) 3so a;' P Approved For Release 2 108/017: Cl DP96-00788r001300280002-7. Table 2 OPERATIONAL REMOTE VIEWING TASKS (FY 1981) Target Date Viewer #81 7/l/801 #002 9/30/80 10/12/80 12/19/80 #131, #009 J.S. -(JN-Djcember' 1980, 0947Z) 12/22/80 #131 J.S. #lot 1/16/81, 1/17/81 #131, #009 J.S. #11., 1/17/81 #0091 #131 J.S. #12- 4/2/81 #002 #002 J..S.#13,' 4/3/81 J. #14 4/7/81 #002 S. '1, J.S. #151, 4/8/81 #002 4/8/81 #002 J.S. #161 J.S. #17 4/9/81 #002 IL J.S. #18'. 4/21/81 #009 . J.S. #19, 4/24/81 #009 .J.S.#201i~ 6/22/79, 7/5/79 #009 6/8/81, 6/9/81 #002 7/30/81, 8/3/81 #002 8/4/811 8/5/81 #002 19 Approved For Release 2000/08'f"' --496-00788r001300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08107 00280002 ,IA-RJ~F~ -7 Table 2 (concluded) E. Evaluation of the, RV Task A first-generation series of evaluation protocols were developed fc use by analysts in providing numerical estimates of various aspects of t RV product generated~in RV tasks. The returned protocols constitute the basis for contractor evaluation, feedback to the remote viewer, and as input for the computerized data-base management (DBM),, The evaluation protocols submitted to analysts for their completion are provided in Appendix D. A sample returned evaluation protocol (for Site J.S. #17) is included as Appendix E. While awaiting the bulk of evaluation protocols, the contractor has begun development of a computerized data-base management system to handle this material. This system, programmed on a stdnd-alone LSI 11/23 system located in a project classified space, will provide a library/catalog' function of data-base readout by date, site, viewer, etc., and trend analysis functions. 20 CIA -.13 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 P Approved For Release 20 0 0 96-00788r001 300280002-7 V SUMMARY OF THE FY 1981 RV ENHANCEMENT TASK Progress in the FY 1981 RV Enhancement Task can be summarized as follows: (1) Efforts completed: CRV enhancement procedure developed. - All six stages researched - Over 200 CRV practice trials with Swann - Orientation through Stage 3 into Stages 4 and 5 completed. Procedure transmitted to three experienced remote viewers. 16 - Over 60 CRV practice trials each - Orientation through Stage 3 completed Procedure transmitted to one novice remote viewer - Over 50 CRV practice trials - Orientation through Stage 1 completed Data obtained on Sites J.S. #8 through J.S. #22. First-generation evaluation protocols developed, distributed t alysts. (2) Findings to date: Subject to formal evaluation in FY 1982, the multistage approach to RV in the procedure under evaluation appears to be successful in "slowing down" the incoming data, thereby providing some safeguard against natural tendencies toward premature interpretation and analysis on the part of the remote viewer. The use of pre- and pos. calibration trials 1 1 appears to provide usef.ul indica ors for bracketing the quality of data obtained in tasks. O)L. 21 Approved For Release 200 1 . %.#IM-Ku~~-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 Approved For Release '2000/08/07 CIA-R~ 11100280002-7 Results l.abeled- obtained in -as Useful are being asks, where the enhancement procedure under evaluation is being employed. 22 "0 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 vt~rOO1300280002-7 Approved For Release" DP96-00788r001300280002-7 L Appendix A REPRESENTATIVE SAMPLE OF CRV PRACTICE SITES (Swann, 3 through 7 November 1980) 23 Approved For Release 2000/ P96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 SG1A Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 sm Approved For Release 2000/00MT.: -CIA-P -00788rOO1 300280002-7 7 m 0 owl I Appendix B BASK SUMMARY SHEETS 27 Approved For Release 2000 ZDP96-00788rOO1 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2 8/07: CIA -00788r001 300280002-7 '7P96 07- r Appendix B 4S n W International !1~nter woo Date 1 July 1980; 0900 hrs Series .Session No. Target No. J.S. #8 Target L Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette #32 idw Comments: 1. Remote viewing session. carried out.'. with SRI RVer #002. No SRI personnel were invol:ved. 2. Session interviewer. as blind as to the target. Now 3. Pre- and post-session calibration experiments were carried out with targets Oahu, Hawaii and the Dead Sea, respectively. SRI international 29 333 RavP.Q5P"et 50MMIA& 0'8/dr! 1246 Approved For Release 2000/08/07,: CIA 1300280002-7 International Date 30 September 1980; 0911 hrs Series Session No. 2 Target No. J.S. #8 (continued) Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV Tape Cassette 43 Comments: 1. Saw large earthworks. 2. Followedup with a National Geographic calibration (Belfast, Ireland), which was successful. SRI International 30 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park, CA 94025 * (415) 326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP * TWX: 910-373 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : Cl 001300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000~. 96-00788r001300280002-7 International 0 2 October 1980; 0825 hrs Date Series Session No. 3 Target No. J.S. #8 (completed) Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV Tape Cassette 45 Comments: 1. Pre-session and post-session calibration scans of San Juan, Puerto Rico and Stornoway, Scotland were successful. 2. Continued description of immense facility, both overground and underground. SRI. International 31 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park. CA 94025 (415) 326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP - TWX: 910-373-1246 MW Approved For Release 2000 6-00788r001 300280002-7 /~E 1 10 f I Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : (CA,, " ? ~001300280002-7 international Q41n7ter,,,) Date 19 December 1980; 1823 hrs .Series. Session No. Target No. J.S. #9 Target Remote Viewer #131 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 100 & 101 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthoffl on this da 2. Remote viewer blind as to target location, event, etc. Interviewer knowledgeable only that event.was suspected nuclear, but blind as to target, country, etc. 3. Two calibration experiments with Nat'l Geographic targets were carrie( it out to determine whether remote viewer was "on-line , one prior to target (Yosemite Park, CA), and one mid-session on ;jMuscat, Oman); both were excellent. 4. Without prompting or cue, remote viewer described location as an islan SRI International 32 333 Ravenswood Ave. * Menlo Park. CA 94025 (415) 326-6200 , Cabie: SRI INTL MNP # TWX: 910-3: Approved For Release 2000/08/07: Clt~ _,7~_~1300280002-7 Approved For Release 200 r17 r11A-0nfm96-00788rOO1 300280002-7 Q jInter Date 22 December 1980; 1555 hrs Series AW Session No 2 (completed) . Target No. J. S'. #9 so Target Remote Viewer #131 Interviewer Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 102 Comments: 1. Continuation of Session 16--see comments there. 2. Coordinates of~ ~given. 3. Purpose of session primarily to obtain answers to questions on first s"ession SRI international 33 333 Ravenswood Ave. Menlo Park, CA 94025 (415).326-6200 Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX:910-3-3-1246 Approved For Release 2000/c, 6-00788rOO1300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 CIA-R flf"?00700280002-7 International %Inter Date 16 January 1981, 1550 hrs Series Session No. Target No. J.S. #10 Target Remote Viewer#131 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette105 & 108 Comments: 1. Coordinates supplied to interviewer Puthof entering into session. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location, activity of interest,.etc. 3. Calibration experiment with Nat'l Geographic target carried out just prior to tas,k result good, remote viewer "on-line. 4.. SRI international 34 333 Ravenswood Ave. e Menlo Park. CA 94025 (415)326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP - TWX:91C Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA- "00280002-7 Approved For Release 20 DP96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 S \1fifiernational CInter) 17 January 1981; 0911 hrs Date Series Session No. Target No. J. S. #10 Target Remote Viewer #009 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 106 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthofz - on 16 January when RVer #131 targeted. 2. Remote viewer blind as to target location, activity of interest, etc. Interviewer knowledgeable only as to target country. SRI international 35 33AOavenswojd Ave. , Menlo Park, CA 94025 - (415) 326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP - TWX: 910-373-1246 pro For Release 2000/ '7 . f%1 A 6-00788rOOl 300280002-7 Approved For Release 200010810 .7 :. CIA-Rcr 00280002-7 As"I M Intemationai !Intter ~) Date 17. January 1981; 1230 hrs Series Session No. Target No. J.S..#Il Target 4. Remote Viewer.. #131 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 109 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthoff 2- At session start remote Viewer and int -.,...*on 16 Janu, erviewer blind as to target location and target activity of interest. Mid-session, interviewer consulted atlas and became thereby knowledgeable as to target country- this was not made known to the remote viewer. 3. Calibration experiment with Nat'l Geographi c target carried out just prior to _ target (calib., Flores, Guatemala); result good, indicating remote viewer "on-line." SRI International 36 333 Ravenswood Ave. o Menlo Park, CA 94025 (415) 326-6200 - Cable; SRI INTL MNP - TWX: 910-37_2 r001 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000108107 Date 17 January 1981; 1230 hrs Series Session No. Target.No. J.S. #11 Target Remote Viewer #009 Interviewer Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) (Coordinates not given to viewer; "Target" phrase used instead) Tape Cassette 107 Comments: 1. At session start remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity of interest. Mid-session, interviewer consulted atlas and became thereby knowledgeable as to target country--this was not made known to remote viewer. 2. 37 SRI. International 333 Ravenswood Ave. Menlo Park, CA 94025 (415)326-6200 Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX:910-373.1,. 11002-7 -DP96-00788rOOl 30028C Approved For Release 2 r 6f C 001300280002-7 Approved Fo Re 6alse 2000/08/07 DPqr%-nn Intemationall %Inte Date 2 April 1981; 0912 hrs Series Session No. Target No. Target Tape Cassette Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) 110 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthoff.~ 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity of interest. 3. Pre-session-calibration experiment with Nat'l Geographic target (Buenos Aires, Argentina) yielded good results, indicating high probability that remote viewer "on-line " to start. Post-session calibration (Dusky Sound, New Z ealand) was equivocal, indicating that the_.remote viewer may have gone 11 off-line" during or after the viewing. Caution is therefore advised. 4. Viewer described a "science-city" type of site, with radio towers chemical storagb, and medical facilities. SRI international J.S. #12 38 333-13aveRgodAve. - M7nIo Park.. CA 94025 - (415)326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP - TWX:910-2 Approved For e ease 2000 08/07 . CLA-OrNcla~"--- - --001300280002-7 1W Approved For Release 2007,n7 rlA_ P96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 International TInter Date 3 April 1981; 0905 hrs Series Session No. Target No. J.S. #13 Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette ill Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewe3.,Ir Iwe 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity of interest. 3. Pre-session calibration experiment with Nat'l Geographic target (Istanbul, Turkey) yielded good results, indicating high probability that remote viewer "on-line" to start. Post-session calibration (Mt. Ararat, Turkey) "off-line," indicating possibility that target of interest might be equivocal. Remote viewer's confidence low, aborts. 4. Viewer describes large noisy factory with cranes, and water contained by stone walls. SRI International 39 333 Ravenswood Ave. 9 Menlo Park. CA 94025 - (415)326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP - TWX:910-373-1246 Approved For Release 200fvnR/n7 r'lA DID96-00788rOO1300280002-.7 _f00280002 Approved For Release 2000108/07: CIA.RCr_-- -7 International %Inter ,,,) Date 7 April ig8i; 0928 hrs Series. Session No. Target No. J.S. #14 Target Remote Viewer. #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 112 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthoff 2. Remote Viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity. 3. Pre-session cal 'ibration experiment with Nat'l Geographic targets (Zagreb, Yugoslavia, and Monument Valley, Utah) yielded good results, indicating high probability that remote viewer "on-line" to start. Post-session calibrations (Jordan River; San Antonio, Texas) good and poor, respectively, indicating some fatigue in functioning toward end. Some caution with regard to target should therefore be exercised. 4. Remote viewer described.vast structures, partly subterranean, with storage function. SRI International 40 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park, CA 94025 - (415) 326-6200 , Cable: SRI INTL MNP - TWX: 910-3' * . rOO1300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000108107 Approved For"Release 2000/~ M96-00788r001 300280002-7 Intemational/ Date 8 April 1981; 0827 hrs Series Session No. Target No. J.S. #15 Target Remote Viewer #0.02 H. Puthoff Interviewer Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 113 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthoff* 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity. 3. Pre-session calibration experiments with Nat'l Geographic targets (Mt. McKinley, Sea of Galilee, Grand Canyon, St. Vincent Island) yielded accepta ble results, indicating fair probability that remote viewer on-line to start. Mid-session calibration (Chapala dry lake bed, Mexico) of medium quality. Post-session calibrations (Great Salt Lake, Utah, Robinson Crusoe Island, Mt. Ararat) of good quality. Overall expectation for: target--medium quality. Wd 4. Remote viewer des.cribed what appears to be a~jW facility. 41 MW SRI International 333 Ravenswood Ave. o Menlo Park. CA94025 (415)326-6200 a Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX:910-3743-1246 Im Approved For Release 200 6-00788r001 300280002-7 ( ~_rc __~19 r Approved For Release 2000/08/07 l3rOO1300280002-7 471== International jInter Date 8 April 1981; 1055 hrs S eries Session No. j . . M Target No. J.S. #16 Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 114 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer PuthoffV-mw ---- --- 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity. 3. Remote viewer described large facility, energy producing, perhaps nuclear reactor. 42 mod SRI International 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park. CA 94025 - (415) 326-6200 Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX: 910-373-1 no Approved For Release 2000/08/07 ir ~~MO1300280002-7 Approved For Release _2GO RDP96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 Nontemational TInte ZIZ,3) 4W W 9 April 1981; 0853 0919 hrs Date Series Session No. Ta.rget No. j.S. #17 Target WW Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (coordinate Remote Viewing) no Tape Cassette 115 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthoff. Coordinate was supposed to be that of J.S. #16 1' ., I- but the latitude number was 18" off, being given as 02" instead of 20", somewhat less than 600 yards off. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location.and target activity of interest. 3. Pre- and post-session calibration experiments with Nat'l Geographic target material (Mount Kilimanjaro and Canyonlands Nat'l Park, Utah, respectively) yielded good results, indicati pg with high probability that remote viewer was "on-line" throughout viewing. 4. so SRI international 43 333 Ravenswood -~ve. * Menlo Park. CA 94025 4 (415) 326-61200 Cable: SRI INTL MNP * TWX: 910-3*73-1246 Approved For Release 200 rt twy '- f%I A 300280002-7 Approved For Release 20 .00108107: CIA-A _)l 300280002-7 Internationai Date 21 April 1981; 0900 hrs Series Session No. Target No. J.S.. #18 Target Remote viewer #009 Interviewer Beacon(s) "Target" Tape Cassette 116 Comments: 1. RV session run by 4_90 T R SRI personnel not involved. 2. Remote. viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity of interest. 3. Pre-session calib'ration experiment with.Nat'l Geographic target material (a site in Ireland) yielded good results, indicating remote viewer "on-line" at session start. SRI international 44 333 Ravenswood Ave. * Menlo Park, CA 94025 (415)326-6200 Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX:910-37", ....,,_~rO01 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIL,_iw. Approved For Release .2000itj- ---?6-00788rOO13OO280002-7. F International Date 24 April 1981; 0835 hrs Series Session No. Target No. J.S. #19 Target Remote Viewer #009 interviewer Beacon(s) Target" Tape Cassette 117 Comments: 1. RV session run by IWOTR SRI personnel not involved. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as. to target location and target activity of interest. 3. Pre- and post-session calibration experiments with Nat'l Geographic target material (Sea of Galilee area; St. Vincent Is., Windward Is.f respectively) yielded good results, indicating with good probability that remote viewer "on-line" during viewing. 4. Remote viewer described experimental site, high-energy technology. 45 SRI international 333 Ravenswood Ave. 9 Menlo Park, CA94025 (415) 326-6200 Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX: 910-373-1246 Approved For Release 20 .7 96-00.788rOOl 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/0.7 W. )01300280002-7 Intemation2l Date 8 June 1981, 0859 hrs (session 1); 9 June$ 0854 hrs (Session 2) Series session No. Target No. J.S. #20 Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 118 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer --Rat beginning of Session 1. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity of interest. 3. Pre- and post-calibration experiments with Nat'l Geographic target M materials yielded good results, indicating with good probability that remote viewer was "on-line" during iewings. No 4. Session 1: Pre Valdez, Alaska; Bora Bora; Port-Said; Post Sitankai Session 2: PreaBeachway, RI; Post ount Rainier. A SRI international 46 333 Ravenswood Ave, - Menlo Park. CA 94025 14151326-6200 - Cable: ffdbbb~Nj - TWX:910-373- Approved For Release 2000108107 IA-RDP96-0 788r0 7 Eli Approved For Release 2~1, PP96-00788rOO1 300280002-17 International Date 30 July 1981; 0907 hrs (Session 3) Series Session No. 3 Target No. J.S. #20 Target Remote viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Bea con (s CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette #119 Comments: 1. Continuation of scans carried out on 6/ '8/81, 6/9/81. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and activity of interest. 3. Pre- and post-session calibration experiments with Nat'l. Geographic materials yielded good results (although post-session somewhat weaker), indicating with good probability that remote viewer was "on-line" during viewings, although not with great depth of contact.* 4.jM so Pre-session calibration: Mt. Kilimanjaro, Aruba Island; Post-session calibration: Seattle, Washington. SRI International 47 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park, CA 94025 -(415) 326-6200 * Cable: SRI INTL MNP * TWX: 910-373-1246 Approved For Release DP96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 C~#: 001300280002-7 International W Date - . 3 August 1981, 08-15 hrs (session 4) Series -. am Session No. 4 Target No. J.S. #20 Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette #120 Comments: I. Continuation of scans carried out on 6/8/81, 6/9/81, 7/30/81. 2. Remote Viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and activity of interest. 3. Pre- and post-session calibration experiments with Nat'l. Geographic materials yielded good results, indicating with good probability that I remote -viewer was "on-line" during,~, Piewings.* 4.1 so Pre-session calibrations: Antwerp, Belgium; Bora Bora Island Post-session calibration: Erciyas Dagi (Mountain), Turkey. EW me SRI International 48 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park. CA 94025 (415) 326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX: 910-37'~ NOW Approved For Release 2000/08/07.: J78rO01 300280002-7 Approved For Release ;(01, ~ORDP96-0078&001 300280002-7 international tInter Date 4 August 1981, 0825 hrs (Session 5) Series Session No. 5 Target No. J.S~. #20 Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette #121 Comments: 1. Continuation of scans carried out on 6,8/81, 6/9/81, 7/30,81, 8/3/81. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and activity of interest. 3. Pre-session calibration experiments with Nat'l. Geographic materials yielded good results; post-session calibration experiments yielded correct descriptions but weak interpretations, indicating viewer went somewhat "off-line" during overall sequence.* 4. Pre-session calibrations: Agung volcano; Florence, Italy Post-session calibrations: Robinson Crusoe Island; Dubrovnik, Yugoslavia. OW SRI International 49 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park. CA 94025 - (415) 326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP 0 TWX: 910-373-1246 Approved For Release 2 -R~P96-0078&001 300280002-7 CO - Approved For Release 2000/08/07 Cl 001360280002-7 International tInter Date 5 August 1981, 0825 hrs (Session 6) Series Session No. 6 Target No. J.S. #20 Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette #122 Comments: 1. Continuation of scans carried out on 6/8/81, 6/'9/81, 7/30/81, 8/3/81, 8/4/81. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and activit,, of interest. 3. Pre- and post-session calibration experiments with Nat'l. Geographic materials yielded good results, indicatin with good probability that remote viewer was "on-line" during ..viewings.* 4. Pre-session calibration: Mt. Shasta Post-session calibration: Vienna, Austria. SRI international 50 333 Ravenswood Ave. a Menlo Park, CA 94025 (415) 326-6200 Cable: SRI INTL MNP TWX: 910-37 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 001300280002-7 ~~,F r r MW Approved For Release 2000/08/07 CIA-RDP96-0078MO1300280002-7 EN FU international) Date 6 August 19.81; 0810 hrs series Session No. MW Target No. J.S. #21 Target AN Remote Viewer #002 go Interviewer H. Puthoff Bea con (s ) CRV (coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 123 Comments: 1. Coordinat e supplied to interviewer Puthoff at session start 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target loeation and target activity of interest. 3. Pre-, mid-, and post-session calibration experiments with Nat'l. 1W Geographic target material (Hong Kong; Mt. Hood; and Kotor, Yugoslavia, respectively) yielded good results. 4. Remote viewer describes complex of buildings, with site having to do with high-energy, high-technology activity. SRI International 51 333 RavAPPEOWO-d ForeReteassw2WO/08ffl?) 3-1246 02. Approved For Release 2000/08107 Cl 001300280002-7 14BF11 International Ift Date 15 September 1981; 08-58 hrs Series EM Session No. Target No. J.S. #22,~r Target Remote Viewer #009 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) "Target " Tape Cassette 124 Comments: 1. Session monitored 211. Remote viewer, interviewer and monitor blind as to target location and target activity of interest. 3. Site accessed by abstract "Target," taken to correspond with a site chosen W-bl CCTR nd known only to him at time of session. 4. Pre-session calibration with Nat'l. Geographic target site- (Dubrovnik, Yugoslavia) good, indicating good conditions going into,~.- WW session. 5. Remote viewer described airfield location and associated buildings, including some interiors. . SRI international 52 333 Ravenswood Ave. - Menlo Park. CA 94025 (415) 326-6200 - Cablei SRI INTL MNP TWX: 910-37, Approved For Release 2000108/07 _'~M`1300280002-7 mol Apprroved For Release 2000/ ZDP96-00788r001 300280002-7 Appendix C AN EXAMPLE OF A REMOTEVIEWING RESPONSE 53 Approved For Release %..IA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 f Md old Mai Approved For Release 200010d., - ?16-00788rOOl 300280002-7 Appendix C International tInte ~) Date 9 April 1981; 0853 0919 hrs Series mom Session No. Target No. J.S. #17 Target Remote Viewer #002 Interviewer H. Puthoff Beacon(s) CRV (Coordinate Remote Viewing) Tape Cassette 115 Comments: 1. Coordinate supplied to interviewer Puthoff Coordinate was supposed to be that of J.S. #16: but the latitude number was 18" off, being give_ln as 02" instead of 20", somewhat less than 600 yards off. 2. Remote viewer and interviewer blind as to target location and target activity of interest. 3. 4. Pre- and post-session calibration experiments with Nat'l. Geographic target material (Mount Kilimanjaro and Canyonlands Nat'l. Park, Utah, respectively) yielded good results, indicating with high probability that remote viewer was "on-line" throughout ,jyiewing. SRI International 55 333 Ravens wood Ave, - Menlo Park. CA94025 (415)326-6200 - Cable: SRI INTL MNP - TWX:910-3-3-1246 Approved For Release 200 ' ')T7m96-00788rOO1 300280002-7 O~ F Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-0QZ88rOO13OO280002-7 J.S. #17 Remote Viewer: 002 monitor: Hal Puthoff 9 April 1981 H: Today is April 9, 1981, Remote Viewer 002 and Hal Puthoff monitoring. 4 J.S. #17. It is 8:53. ---------- aw 56 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 Approved For Release 2077 rI7 96-00788r001300280002-7 T V Iwo *AOL Analytical overlay; images thought to be erroneous, being triggered imagination. Possibly relevant, but not taken to be primary data. 57 Approved For Release DP96-00788r001 300280002-7 002 8107 . CIA-R7r,-nnI22nC 80002-7.,. Approved For Release 200010 J_ I. ~... V: This is a terrible place for some reason. I am having words like med biological, research, human use, human guinea pigs rather, prison fac H V Chemicals and gas, a biological warfare place. This is like a decompression chamber. Maybe those are contamination chambers. Oh dear, what did we find. Who gave this coordinate? I came across it seems to be five rather complex chambers in a very large hangar like building. They remind me of the decompression chamber that we saw down at that marine research base on Catalina. A decompression place where people went if they came up from diving too fast. A complex chamber made of reinforced steel and concrete and things and it has tanks. They have tanks of various kinds leading into them. 5. C'& *AOL - See pr'evious page CAA 01 -AA 58 0/081 i~MO`1300280002-7 Approved For Release 200 -- r 0788rOO1300280002-7 prov r Ap e dFor Release 2007- V: There is the smell of disinfectant and ultra violet lights, purple light, lavendar light, inside this large hangar like building. The floor seems wet. People wear boots, very large rubber boots. There seem to be inside stairs going down. This place is maybe 40 ft high at least. There are these chamber units there, but there are stairs and:an elevator going down. And a ramp and lift forks, so this is underground too. It's funny, there seems to be windows on the outside, but there aren't any windows on the inside. Fake windows. I seem to see what looks like a guard cubicle because it has all glass around, it is inside the building. It has, by comparison to the other cold lavendar lights, it has yellow illumination in it. There are six men there. There -is a big panel, it seems to be a voltage control panel for some sort of electronics system. Down the ramp are very long corridors. It looks like storage. There are signs everywhere. I can't read the characters but the phoenetics is sort of There are blinking red lights over some doors here and there. I think these are exit markers. dw Approved For Release P96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/08107 : CIA.rha nn7QQr 0280002-7 7 V: Outside the ground isn't flat, it is sort of like there are hills or artificially made mounds that sort of divide up this compound in a way. Buildings that look like barracks. A whole series of buildings that look like prefabricate boxes, that are sort of all stacked together. Water tank on the hill. Large tower I think and in the area there is an airstrip. It is about 2 miles to the NE I think. I am going to end there. I don't like this place. At that Class A site there was a tall thing that I couldn't make out, I bet that that is a chimmney. I bet those are large furnaces. 60 )0788r001 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000108107.: ~. f Approved For Release 2000/08/07:,CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl3OO280002-7 c Appendix D RV EVALUATION PROTOCOLS Approved For Release 20 61 96-00788r001 300280002-7 Approved For Release 2009=2107 - f"~~'~P96-00.78MO1300280002-7 Appendix D INSTPJJCTIONS TO ANALYSTS (U) M The information provided asenclosure to this report was obtained in response to a collection requirement provided by This information was acquired from a new and potentially valuable source Work is currently being pursued to determine the accuracy, reliability., and improvement potential of this source. Your remarks and attention to the evaluation sheet will be the basis for our assessment of this new collection technique. Therefore, the effort you expend will greatly assist us and will ultimately result in you receiving more data of increasing accuracy and reliability. (U) While formulating your judgements concerning the data, the following comments concerning this new source of In-('Dr-ry1a--HoA may be helpful. (U) Foremost, the data is likely to consist of a mixture of correct and incorrect elements. Specifically: (1) M The descriptive elements are generally of higher reliability than Judgements or labels as to what is being described (recreational swimming pool may be mistaken for water purification pools; an aircraft hull may be mistaken for a submarine hull, etc.). Therefore, seemingly appropriate descriptive elements should not be rejected because of mislabeling. (2) ORThe data often contain gaps (in a 3-building complex, for example, perhaps only two of the buildings may be described, and an airfield may be added that isn't there). Such gaps or additions should not be taken to mean that the rest of the data is necessarily inaccurate. Aw'herefore a recommended approach is to first examine the entire information packet to obtain an overall "flavor" of the response, reserving final judgement even in the face of certain errors, and then go back through for detailed analysis. (U) If you have questions regarding the data you have received or on its evaluation please feel free to contact me at any time. Thank you. 63 Approved For Release 200 6-00788rOOl 300280002-7 t a a-- I t t I SUMMRY EVALUATION SIEET (U) (U) For the summary evaluation, please check t*heollowing boxes as to the accuracy of the submitted material. ACCURACY Site Contact, > > Little with Not -a Co rrespondence d ResultsGood Excellent UnknownApplicable Mixe 0 1 2 3 0 0 < < (D (D Geographical locale descrip- CL tion (terrain, water, etc.) ED D ED -n CL -n 0 0 e.Large-scale mawaade elements l (cities, buildings, silos, (D d li s d i1 k (D ne roa oc s, ra ,, airfields) etc.) W Small-scale manmade elements (D . IM 1antennas, computers P- of f ices, etc.) :General target ambience .(re- Q search..Production. adminis-, 00 tration, storage 17 CD En -etc.) 0 Relevant specific activities > CD SPersonality inf ormation ] CD (physical descriptions, CD CD actions, responsibilities, 4 4 plans, etc.) 00 00 00 00 -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ol CD - CD Cannot de- CD be _L CD Overall utility None Marginal Useful Ver y Useful terminedat this time - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - CD - CD M (U) Definitions for the accuracy 00 scale: 00 0 - Little correspondence . . Self explanatory. CD CD . . . CD CD 1 - Site contact with . . . . Mixture of correctand incorrect of the rmer to CD . . . elements., fo but enough CD mixed results indicate sources probably the target ~j M ha accessed site. 2 - Good . . . . . . . . . . . Good correspondence with 44 . . several elements matching, but some incorrect information. -4 3 - Excellent . . . . . . . . Good correspondence with unique matchableelementsand relatively . . . unambiguous little incorrectnformatibn. i t > SUMMARY EVALUATION PERSONNEL SHEET (U) (U) For the summary evaluation,check the the material, CD 0 please following accuracy CL boxes as of to the submitted < -n M ACCURACY 0 CL -n Personnel 0 Little ConLact, v-'ith Not CorrespondenceMixed ResultsGood Excellent Unknown Applicable 0 1 2 3 CD Geographical locale description Q ED F-1 F~ Q Dress appearance (uniform, Q Q e Q formal, casual, etc.) 7 7 D F F 7 F F F 00 D Q Q Q Physical appearance (height, 4 00 D D 7 D ~ ~ Q we ight, scars, hair color etc.) 0 -4 General health characteristics D Nati onality ED E7 F7 Personality characteristics mental, state, demeanor, etc.) 7 ED F-1 a) F El ED Relevant past responsibilities/F7 ED ED ED ED D activities 1WRelevant current responsibilities/activities Q Q Q Relevant planned Q Is "a responsibilities/activities 00 Q Q Governments, agencies, persons Q 00 - Q Q responsible to/associated with 7 1 1:1 El E Q - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Q - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - !4 - - Cannot -*Wverall utility NoneF__1 Marginal Useful El Very be - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Useful de- - - - - - - - - - F-1 termined - at - this - time - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - (U) Definitions for the accuracy scale: 0 Little correspondence . . . Self explanatory. . . I Site COntaCt WiLh . . . . . Mixture rect and incorrect of former to . . of cor elements), the but enough mixed results indicate source the target has probably site. accessed 2 Good . . . . . . . . . . . . 'Good corres . pond eno e with st-rc-1 Approved For Release 2000/08107: CIA-RDP9670078MO1300280002-7 ow =9 ow mmi im mw DETAILED EVALUATION SHEET (U) Specific Transcript/Drawing Items 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 10. Evaluation Reference 12. 0 to 3 point scale of previous page. Approved For, Release 200 8/07 :6dlA-RPPq6-00788r001 300280002-7 7 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : C npa,-, 01300280002-7. Additional information desired? Priority YesF-1 Urgent date No r-1 Routine M Items I. 2. 3. 4. 68 -7 Approved For Release 2000/08/ 88r001300280002 2000108707 CIA-RDP96-00788r001300280002-7 m Appendix E A SAMPLE RETURNED EVALUATION PROTOCOL Mimi Approved For Release 2000/08/0t9: CIA-RDP96-00788rOOl 300280002-7 t t Agroved For Release 0/6TW ft-Abftd'-6&6)i~001300286b62-7!-" (U) For the summary eva U tion, please check the following boxes as to the accuracy of the submitted material. ACCURACY Little Correspondence 0 Site Contact, with Mixed Results 1 Not Good Excellent Unknown Applicable 2 3 Geographical locale descrip- FZ71 tion (terrain, water, etc.) E7 ID Li Large-scale manmade elements (citiesybuildings, silos, ED docks, railroad. lines, ..airfields, etc.) Small-scale manmade elements antennas., computers, offices" etc.) gner ii,ti~get ambience. (re-' C gi,~P.;oduction', admini's 7 J - n ~qrag . Z 4 C V ti it ids Personality information (physical descriptions'...:.. actions, responsibilities plans, etc.) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - verall utility None Marginal - - -0 1- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Useful Very Useful - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Cannot be de- termined at this time - - - - - - - - - - - - - - (U) Definitions for the accuracy scale: 0 - Little correspondence . . . Self explanatory. . . 1 - Site contact with . . . . . Mixture of ntsil but of former to . . correct and enough the incorrect eleme mixed results indicate source the target has probably site. accessed 2 - Good . . . . . Good correspondence nts matching, incorrect information. with several but some eleme 3 - Excellent . . . . . . . . . Good correspondence nique matchableelements . . with unambiguous and u relatively little incorrectinformation. Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00788r001300280002-7 130028000 2-7 Approved For Release 2000108107 CIAC '7 77 DETAILED EVALUATION SHEET (U) Specific Transcript/Drawing Items Evaluation Referenc 2. AKJ 3. G -e 4;- 4r tj 4. LA I'l n e 5. 6. k ., tz 7. 4~L L4 t/ 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 0 to 3 point scale of previous page. 72 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 -~J88 001300280002-7 Approved For Release 2000/ 8/071: CIA 6-00788rOO1 300280002-7 7. 7 7 Additio nal information desired? Yes No 40 Priority Urgent F-1 j:4 1,414 C, RoutineFA date Items 1. e- <- Z c! X S Ck 2. L) 11 PO a en, rye f, Ott u 3. 4.